When it comes to bathroom renovations, one of the biggest decisions homeowners face is whether to opt for a bathtub replacement or go for a bathtub conversion. Both choices come with their own set of benefits, design considerations, and long-term implications for comfort and resale value. The bathroom is more than just a utilitarian space—it’s a place to unwind, refresh, and recharge. Making the right decision during a remodel is crucial for ensuring your bathroom not only suits your lifestyle but also adds value to your home.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about tub to shower conversion, replacing a bathtub, and the pros and cons of each option. Whether you’re leaning toward a luxurious soak in a new tub or considering a sleek, space-saving walk-in shower conversion, we’ve got you covered.
Understanding the Basics of Bathtub Replacement
A bathtub replacement involves removing your existing tub and installing a new one—often with updated materials, dimensions, or styles. This is ideal for homeowners who enjoy the relaxation a bath provides but want a more modern or functional tub. Whether your current tub is outdated, damaged, or simply not your style, replacing it can give your bathroom a fresh new look while retaining the bathing experience.
There are many modern bathtub replacement options available, ranging from deep soaking tubs and freestanding models to alcove bathtubs and whirlpool options. Material choices include acrylic, fiberglass, enameled steel, and cast iron, each offering a different feel, price point, and durability level. If your goal is to maintain the traditional bath aesthetic while upgrading its features, then a replacement may be your best bet.
What Is a Bathtub Conversion?
A bathtub conversion, especially a tub to shower conversion, is the process of removing a bathtub and replacing it with a walk-in shower. This type of remodel is increasingly popular among homeowners seeking a more functional, space-efficient bathroom. Many people—especially seniors or those with mobility concerns—prefer showers due to ease of access and quicker use.
In a bathtub to shower remodel, the bathtub is replaced with a shower enclosure, often with a low threshold or curb-free entry. This approach not only adds modern appeal but also improves safety, reduces water use, and provides more design flexibility. If you rarely take baths, this could be the most practical way to transform your bathroom into a more usable space.
Bathtub vs Shower Conversion: Which One Is Right for You?
Deciding between a bathtub vs shower conversion depends on your lifestyle, household needs, and long-term goals for your home. If you enjoy long, relaxing baths or have small children who require a tub, replacing your existing tub with a new one makes sense. A new tub can modernize your space while still preserving bathing functionality.
On the other hand, if your bathtub is rarely used and you’re looking to maximize space, improve accessibility, or add a sleek, spa-like design, a walk-in shower conversion could be ideal. Showers offer faster, more efficient use and can make a bathroom appear larger and more open. Ultimately, the best choice is the one that aligns with your personal habits and future resale expectations.
Key Considerations Before Choosing
Before making a final decision between bathtub replacement and bathtub conversion, it’s important to weigh several factors that can impact your project’s outcome.
Functionality: Think about who uses the bathroom and how often. A growing family with young kids may need a bathtub, while a busy professional might prioritize a quick shower setup.
Space Constraints: In smaller bathrooms, removing the tub and installing a walk-in shower can make the room feel significantly more spacious. This is a major selling point for homeowners with compact layouts.
Design Preferences: Tubs lend themselves to classic, elegant designs, while showers provide a more modern, minimalist aesthetic. The materials, finishes, and layouts available for both options are nearly endless.
Accessibility: Showers are typically easier to enter and exit, particularly when designed with low thresholds or curbless entries. Adding grab bars, built-in benches, and handheld showerheads further improves safety.
Home Resale Value: While many buyers appreciate the convenience of a walk-in shower, families may prefer at least one tub in the home. If you’re planning to sell, it may be wise to keep a tub in at least one bathroom.
Exploring the Cost to Replace Bathtub vs Conversion
Budget is another important consideration when comparing bathtub remodel options. The cost to replace a bathtub varies depending on the type of tub, the complexity of the removal, and any required plumbing changes. On average, homeowners spend between $1,200 and $4,500 for a full tub replacement.
Bathtub conversion costs, particularly a convert bathtub to walk-in shower project, typically range from $2,500 to $7,500 depending on materials, finishes, and labor involved. More extensive conversions—such as those involving custom tile work or expanded footprints—can exceed $10,000.
Though conversions may come at a higher price initially, they can provide long-term savings by reducing water use and maintenance needs. Plus, the added convenience and appeal of a walk-in shower can be well worth the investment.
Popular Bathtub Remodel Options to Consider
If you’re leaning toward replacing your bathtub, there’s no shortage of stylish, practical bathtub remodel options available. Here are a few ideas to inspire your renovation:
- Deep Soaking Tubs: Designed for maximum comfort, these tubs are ideal for relaxing baths and luxurious bathroom aesthetics.
- Freestanding Tubs: A popular trend in modern bathrooms, freestanding tubs create a high-end look and often become the focal point of the room.
- Whirlpool or Air Tubs: Perfect for those seeking a therapeutic experience, these tubs provide hydrotherapy features to soothe tired muscles.
- Drop-In Tubs: Installed into a deck or surround, drop-in tubs offer a seamless, built-in appearance that works well in both modern and traditional designs.
These options can be customized with tile surrounds, new fixtures, and built-in storage to enhance usability and aesthetics.
Benefits of Replacing Bathtub with Walk-In Shower
If a bathtub to shower remodel is more appealing, you’ll enjoy numerous benefits beyond style. Replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower can dramatically transform your bathroom’s functionality, making it safer and more comfortable for daily use.
A walk-in shower is especially beneficial for aging homeowners or those with limited mobility. When designed with slip-resistant flooring, barrier-free entry, and adjustable showerheads, it becomes a practical and safe solution for everyone. Additionally, showers are generally quicker and more efficient than baths, making them a time-saving feature in busy households.
A walk-in shower conversion can also open up the visual space of your bathroom. Frameless glass panels, sleek tiles, and floating benches create a clean, modern aesthetic that appeals to both current owners and potential buyers.
Pros and Cons of Bathtub Conversion
Every remodel decision comes with pros and cons, and a bathtub conversion is no exception. Here’s a breakdown to help guide your choice:
Pros:
- Enhances accessibility and safety
- Increases available space in the bathroom
- Offers a modern, clean design
- Reduces water consumption
- Easier to maintain than a bathtub
Cons:
- Eliminates the option to take a bath
- May affect resale value for families with young children
- Conversion costs can be higher than replacement
- Plumbing adjustments may be required
Carefully consider these factors, especially if your home only has one bathtub. It may be worth keeping one tub elsewhere in the home for long-term flexibility.
Making the Right Choice for Your Bathroom
Whether you choose bathtub replacement or bathtub conversion, the key is to align your remodel with your current lifestyle and future goals. Think about how you use the space every day and what would make your routine more enjoyable and efficient.
Working with experienced bathroom remodelers like Next Level Showers, LLC ensures that your project is handled with care, professionalism, and expert insight. From consultation to design to installation, we’ll help you make the right decision and bring your vision to life.
